Guide · Original data

Does Expertise.com help local businesses get recommended by AI?

Expertise.com publishes "best of" lists of local businesses, city by city, and AI assistants cite them across most trades we track. It also blocks two of the best-known AI crawlers in its robots.txt. We measured how often the assistants cite it across 4,100 US markets, and read what Expertise.com says about how it picks businesses and what it charges. The numbers are ours; our team opened the outside sources on November 18, 2026.

Quick answer

Often, for home services and lawyers. In our November 2026 data, AI assistants cited Expertise.com in 1,769 of 4,100 US markets, across 17 of 20 trades, for 1.9% of all citations. Its share is highest for garage door repair (4.8%) and water damage restoration (4.6%). It cites businesses it hand-picks, and featured providers pay for placement.

What are the key facts about Expertise.com and AI recommendations?

FactDetailSource
Cited as a source1.9% of all local citations, the 7th most-cited site overall (November 2026)AI Syndicate Research
How widelyCited in 1,769 of 4,100 US markets, across 17 of 20 tradesAI Syndicate Research
Where it matters mostGarage door repair (4.8% of citations), water damage restoration (4.6%), electricians (3.7%)AI Syndicate Research
Which pagesIts city lists: home-improvement lists in 1,350 markets, legal lists in 410AI Syndicate Research
How it picks"We scored... on more than 25 variables across five categories," then a manual review and mystery-shopper callsExpertise.com
Who can ask to be reviewedBusinesses in its Legal and Home Improvement categoriesExpertise.com
Paid placementProviders who pass selection "may choose to advertise on the page"; a monthly agreement pays "for placement"Expertise.com
AI crawlersIts robots.txt blocks GPTBot, ClaudeBot and Claude-Web from the whole siteExpertise.com robots.txt

How often does AI cite Expertise.com?

Across most local trades, at a lower rate than a trade's leading directory. Measured by us, November 2026: AI Syndicate Research asked 12 AI assistants three fixed questions about a type of local business in each of 4,100 US markets, with the city named in the question and no user location or account history. The live-search assistants returned 331,925 citations. AI Syndicate Research

Expertise.com took 1.9% of them (6,266 citations), the 7th most-cited site overall, after Yelp, Google, Facebook, Angi, Reddit and Justia. It was cited in 1,769 markets and in 17 of the 20 trades. AI Syndicate Research

Where AI cites Expertise.com most Expertise.com's share of the citations the live-search assistants returned for each type of business, 205 US markets per trade, November 2026. Measured by AI Syndicate Research.
Show the numbers
Type of businessShare of citations
Garage door repair4.8%
Water damage restoration4.6%
Electricians3.7%
Criminal defense lawyers3.4%
Window and door replacement3.4%
Pest control3.1%
Roofing3.0%
Plumbers2.9%
Personal injury lawyers2.8%

Its reach is uneven:

Type of businessExpertise.com's share of citationsMarkets where it was cited (of 205)
Garage door repair4.8%158
Water damage restoration4.6%165
Electricians3.7%159
Criminal defense lawyers3.4%161
Window and door replacement3.4%138
Pest control3.1%148
Roofing3.0%159
Plumbers2.9%138
Personal injury lawyers2.8%159
HVAC and air conditioning1.5%99
Business litigation lawyers1.5%90
Real estate teams1.5%104

It barely appears for auto repair, speeding ticket lawyers, cosmetic dentists, hotels, med spas and restaurants. Those trades have their own leading sites, such as Carfax, Justia and Tripadvisor. AI Syndicate Research

In 622 markets three or more different assistants cited it. It was the most-cited outside site outright in 66 markets, and tied for first in 73. AI Syndicate Research

In plain words: for home services and lawyers, an Expertise.com list for your city is one of the pages an AI answer may link.

Which Expertise.com pages does AI cite?

Its city lists. For each market, our data keeps one example address for every site cited. For Expertise.com, that address was a city list in almost every case:

  • A home-improvement list in 1,350 markets, such as expertise.com/home-improvement/roofing/alabama/mobile.
  • A legal list in 410 markets, such as expertise.com/legal/litigation-lawyers/arizona/mesa.
  • Another page in the remaining 9.

AI Syndicate Research

The roofing list for Mobile, Alabama shows what such a page holds. "Last updated: November 16, 2026." It says: "We scored Mobile roofers on more than 25 variables across five categories, and analyzed the results to give you a hand-picked list of the best." It counts "82 Reviewed," "54 Curated" and "14 Top Picks," and the first business shown carries a "Featured Provider" label. Expertise.com

In plain words: what matters is whether you're on Expertise.com's list for your trade in your city, and what it says about you.

Expertise.com blocks AI crawlers. Why does AI still cite it?

Because it blocks the training crawlers, not the search ones. Its robots.txt, under the comment "bots to block," lists GPTBot, ClaudeBot and Claude-Web (with three bots that aren't AI crawlers) and gives them Disallow: /, the whole site. Expertise.com robots.txt

The AI companies run separate bots for separate jobs:

CompanyBotWhat it's for, in the company's words
OpenAIGPTBot"Used to crawl content that may be used in training our generative AI foundation models"
OpenAIOAI-SearchBot"Used to surface websites in search results in ChatGPT's search features"
AnthropicClaudeBot"Collecting web content that could potentially contribute to their training"
AnthropicClaude-SearchBot"Navigates the web to improve search result quality for users"
AnthropicClaude-User"Supports Claude AI users. When individuals ask questions to Claude, it may access websites"

OpenAI Anthropic

OpenAI says each setting "is independent of the others," so "a webmaster can allow OAI-SearchBot in order to appear in search results while disallowing GPTBot." OpenAI Expertise.com's file doesn't name OAI-SearchBot, Claude-SearchBot or Claude-User, so they fall under its general rules, which leave the city lists open. Expertise.com robots.txt

We don't know whether Expertise.com set this up on purpose to stay in AI search while opting out of training. Its file doesn't say. The effect, in our data, is a site that blocks two training crawlers and is still cited in 1,769 markets.

The lesson for your own site: blocking GPTBot or ClaudeBot opts you out of training; it doesn't by itself take you out of ChatGPT's or Claude's search answers. Blocking OAI-SearchBot does: OpenAI says sites that opt out of it "will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers." OpenAI Check which bots your robots.txt names before assuming either way. See our guide to AI crawlers and robots.txt.

How does Expertise.com pick the businesses on its lists?

With research it describes in four steps, then a hand-pick. Its selection-process page says it reviews providers "in over 200 industries across the U.S." and researches "more than 60,000 businesses" each month. Expertise.com

  1. Finding candidates. "We use public databases and customer referrals to collect an exhaustive list of local businesses."
  2. Qualifications. It checks which trades need a license and looks for providers who have "gone above and beyond to educate themselves."
  3. Reputation. "Every provider is analyzed based on the number of professional databases reviewing them, their average review score, and the volatility of their ratings."
  4. Finalists and calls. It picks finalists by "primary area of expertise, the variety of services they offer, and their years of experience," then "our mystery shoppers call each company."

Expertise.com

Its About page lists the five things it grades: a history of satisfied customers; licensing, accreditations and awards; years of experience and education; being "approachable and responsive to clients and available for new business"; and consistent quality work. "Our team conducts a manual review to verify that each company on our list is truly one of the best." Expertise.com

Can you ask to be reviewed? In some trades. "We do allow professionals in certain business categories to request a review. Currently, these requests are limited to our Legal and Home Improvement categories." Listed businesses can correct details through a "free Provider Portal." Expertise.com

Do businesses pay to be on Expertise.com?

Not to be selected, by its account, but they can pay for placement once they are. Its selection page says: "Once a provider has passed our review & selection process, they may choose to advertise on the page to increase their visibility to new potential customers." Expertise.com

Its marketing agreement sets the terms: the client "shall pay... the amount agreed to per the Expertise.com invoice in exchange for placement in the corresponding category," billed monthly, and must cancel "within five days of the payment date in order to receive a refund for that month's sponsorship." Expertise.com On the Mobile roofing list we opened, the first business shown was labelled "Featured Provider." Expertise.com

What we couldn't confirm. The pages we opened on November 18, 2026 don't state a price for placement, and don't say whether a featured provider's position affects which businesses an assistant names from the page. We make no claim about either. Our data records which pages assistants cite, not which business on a page they took from it.

What should a local business do about Expertise.com?

Our advice, not an Expertise.com statement, built on our data and on what Expertise.com says publicly.

  1. Check whether it matters in your trade. It took 3% or more of citations for garage door repair, water damage restoration, electricians, criminal defense lawyers, window replacement, pest control and roofing, and almost none for restaurants or med spas. AI Syndicate Research
  2. Find your city's list. Search Expertise.com for your trade and city, and see whether you're on it and what it says.
  3. Correct your details. Listed businesses can update them through the free Provider Portal. Expertise.com
  4. If you're missing and you're a lawyer or in home improvement, request a review. Those are the categories where Expertise.com takes requests. Expertise.com
  5. Make its criteria easy to check. License, years in business, awards and service area, written in plain text on your own website, match what its researchers say they look for. Expertise.com
  6. Price any sponsorship before you sign. Placement is paid monthly; know what it costs and what it changes. Expertise.com
  7. Check your own robots.txt. Make sure you aren't blocking the search crawlers (such as OAI-SearchBot and Claude-SearchBot) if you want to appear in AI answers. OpenAI Anthropic

Is an Expertise.com listing enough on its own?

No. Even in garage door repair, its best trade, Expertise.com took 4.8% of citations; the rest went elsewhere. AI Syndicate Research

No single site decides the answer. An assistant reads several and looks for a business that shows up, with matching details and good reviews, on more than one.

What should be on my Expertise.com checklist for AI?

CheckDone whenSource
Trade checkedYou know Expertise.com's share of citations in your tradeAI Syndicate Research
Business foundYou appear on Expertise.com's list for your trade and cityOur advice
Details rightName, phone, services and description are correct, via the Provider PortalExpertise.com
Review requestedIf missing, and you're legal or home improvement, you've asked for a reviewExpertise.com
Criteria shown in textLicense, years, awards and service area written out on your own siteOur advice
Sponsorship pricedYou know what featured placement costs before you buy itOur advice
Robots.txt checkedYour file doesn't block OAI-SearchBot, Claude-SearchBot or Claude-UserOpenAI; Anthropic
Details match everywhereSame name, address and phone on Expertise.com, Yelp, Google and your siteOur advice
Answers checkedYou've asked the assistants your customers' questionOur advice

Rows marked "Our advice" are ours; every other row comes from the source named. To see which sites AI already cites when it talks about you, run the free AI visibility check.

Sources

  1. AI Local Report, November 2026: AI changed its #1 local pick in 40% of markets in one month, AI Syndicate Research. Read Nov 18, 2026.
  2. Our Selection Process, Expertise.com. Read Nov 18, 2026.
  3. About Us, Expertise.com. Read Nov 18, 2026.
  4. Expertise.com Marketing Agreement, Expertise.com. Read Nov 18, 2026.
  5. Best Roofers in Mobile, AL, Expertise.com. Read Nov 18, 2026.
  6. robots.txt, Expertise.com. Read Nov 18, 2026.
  7. Overview of OpenAI Crawlers, OpenAI. Read Nov 18, 2026.
  8. Does Anthropic crawl data from the web, and how can site owners block the crawler?, Anthropic. Read Nov 18, 2026.
FAQ

Common questions

How often does AI cite Expertise.com?

In our November 2026 data, Expertise.com took 1.9% of the 331,925 citations the live-search assistants returned for local business questions, the 7th most-cited site, and was cited in 1,769 of 4,100 US markets. AI Syndicate Research

Which trades does Expertise.com matter for in AI answers?

Mostly home services and lawyers. Its highest shares were garage door repair (4.8%), water damage restoration (4.6%) and electricians (3.7%). It barely appeared for restaurants, hotels, med spas or auto repair. AI Syndicate Research

Does Expertise.com block AI crawlers?

It blocks GPTBot, ClaudeBot and Claude-Web, which are training crawlers. It does not name OpenAI's or Anthropic's search crawlers, and assistants still cited its pages in 1,769 markets in November 2026. Expertise.com robots.txt

Can a business pay to be on Expertise.com?

Expertise.com says providers who pass its selection process may choose to advertise on the page, and its marketing agreement charges monthly "in exchange for placement." Expertise.com Expertise.com

How do I get my business reviewed by Expertise.com?

Businesses in its Legal and Home Improvement categories can request a review. Listed businesses can update their details through its free Provider Portal. Expertise.com

See which sites AI cites when it recommends businesses like yours.

Enter your domain. The free AI visibility check shows where ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI answers already mention you, and which of your pages AI crawlers can read.