AI profile · Long Island, NY

The Menhaden

themenhaden.com ↗

The Menhaden ranks #9 of 25 among the hotels AI assistants recommend in Long Island, NY, named by 3 of the 12 assistants that answered, up 11 places from #20 in the previous edition.

Own The Menhaden? See why AI ranks you #9, and what moves you up.

AI Pulse from $99/mo →

One-time PDF by email, no subscription. What’s in it · See what AI Pulse looks like

Hotels · Long Island, NY
#9
9th of 25 businesses AI names
▲ 11 since last edition
AI Heat 59 Holding steady
3 of 12 assistants
ChatGPTDeepSeekGemini
Edition of November 1, 2026·5 mentions
#9
Best rank
3/12
Assistants recommending
5
Mentions this edition
1
Category ranked
#20 → #9 ↑

#20 in October 2026, #9 now: moving up across 2 editions.

Missing on key questions

Not in the top 5 for “Recommend” (#8) or “Affordable” (not named).

Silent on voice

Voice answers name only 2–3 businesses, and Siri and Alexa didn't name you.

Where AI names you · preview

AI named The Menhaden in 5 of 35 answers

The glow is New York: blue when the assistants rarely name you, amber when they always do. Every other state shows how settled AI is on hotels there, bright where one business owns the answer and dim where it's up for grabs.

  • ChatGPT1/3
  • Claude0/2
  • Gemini2/3
  • Perplexity0/3
  • Google AI Overviews0/3
  • Microsoft Copilot0/3
  • Siri0/3
  • Alexa0/3
  • Grok0/3
  • Meta AI0/3
  • DeepSeek2/3
  • Mistral0/3

Want the full map? Every city you serve, every assistant, every month, and what to fix where you're dim.

Get AI Pulse from $99/mo →

AI heat map · Hotels

The AI heat map for The Menhaden

The Menhaden was named in 5 of the 35 answers the assistants gave to hotels questions in this edition, in the top 3 of 1. The #1 business, The Garden City Hotel, was named in 15 of 35. AI reach: The Menhaden 6 out of 100, The Garden City Hotel 27. It counts each assistant by how many people use it and each answer by how high the business was named.

Each square is one assistant answering one question. Darker means named higher in the answer. Assistants are listed by how many people use them; the % beside each is how much it counts. Where these come from.
You#1 The Garden City Hotel
AssistantBestRecommendAffordableBestRecommendAffordable
Google AI Overviews30%NoNoNoNoNoNo
ChatGPT23.8%#5NoNoNo#1No
Gemini13%#7#7NoNo#2No
Microsoft Copilot9.2%NoNoNo#1#1No
Meta AI7.6%NoNoNo#2#1No
Grok4.3%NoNoNo#5#1No
Claude3.2%NoNoNoNo
Siri3.2%NoNoNoNo#1No
Alexa3.2%NoNoNo#3#1No
Perplexity1.4%NoNoNoNo#1No
DeepSeek0.5%#7#1No#9+#6No
Mistral0.5%NoNoNoNo#9+No
  • Named first
  • Named top 3
  • Named lower
  • Named someone else
  • No answer

Why the assistants picked The Garden City Hotel

These sites were cited in the answers that named The Garden City Hotel, and in none of the answers that named The Menhaden. That's where your competitor shows up and you don't.

  • expedia.comDirectory & reviews
  • tripadvisor.comDirectory & reviews
  • google.comDirectory & reviews
  • linkedin.comDirectory & reviews
  • en.wikipedia.orgReference

Cited in the same answers, recorded as given. It shows where the leader appears, not proof of why it was picked.

30 cold squares are answers that sent the customer elsewhere. See which sources each assistant read to pick a competitor, and turn the cold squares hot.

or AI Pulse from $99/mo
  • Best: Who are the best hotels in Long Island, NY?
  • Recommend: I need a hotel in Long Island, NY. Who do you recommend?
  • Affordable: Best affordable hotel near Long Island?

Which AI assistants recommend The Menhaden

ChatGPT, DeepSeek and Gemini name The Menhaden when asked for hotels in Long Island, NY. Google AI Overviews, Alexa, Claude, Microsoft Copilot, Grok, Meta AI, Mistral, Perplexity and Siri answered the same questions without naming it. Its strongest question is “Who are the best hotels in Long Island, NY?”, where it ranks #5; on “Best affordable hotel near Long Island?” it is not named. Holiday Inn Long Island–Islip Airport East holds #8, one place ahead, with an AI reach of 8 to The Menhaden's 6. The site cited most often in the answers that name it is gurneysresorts.com (1×).

What “searches the web” and “answers from memory” mean.

ChatGPTRecommends youSearches the web
ClaudeNot naming youSearches the web
GeminiRecommends youSearches the web
PerplexityNot naming youSearches the web
Google AI OverviewsNot naming youSearches the web
Microsoft CopilotNot naming youSearches the web
SiriNot naming youVoice assistant
AlexaNot naming youVoice assistant
GrokNot naming youAnswers from memory
Meta AINot naming youAnswers from memory
DeepSeekRecommends youAnswers from memory
MistralNot naming youAnswers from memory

What the AI assistants say about The Menhaden

Across 5 answers from 3 assistants in the November 2026 edition, this is what they told customers about The Menhaden, in their words, as recorded.

Positive in all 5 answers that described it.

  • Greenport

    DeepSeek
  • 16-room

    Gemini
  • best North Fork hotel

    ChatGPT
  • boutique

    DeepSeek
  • access to Shelter Island ferry

    Gemini
  • complimentary bicycles

    ChatGPT
  • stylish boutique hotel near the harbor

    DeepSeek
  • complimentary local shuttle bikes

    Gemini
  • retained a Michelin Key in 2026 selection

    ChatGPT
  • walkable to town

    DeepSeek
  • historic Greenport Village

    Gemini
  • rooftop deck

    ChatGPT

These are the assistants' own statements about The Menhaden when asked for hotels in Long Island, NY, recorded as given. We don't verify them. An assistant can be out of date or wrong, and that is exactly what a business needs to know. How these are recorded.

Rank, movement and who's ahead

Each ranking The Menhaden holds in Long Island, NY, how it has moved edition to edition, and the businesses directly above and below it.

Long Island, NY

Hotels

▲ 11 since last edition
#9of 25
Rank history
#1#10#20#20#9Oct 2026Nov 2026

2 editions on record. #1 is the top spot, so a rising line means climbing the ranks.

Who's around you

The gap to close: these 3 assistants name a business ranked above you, but not you.Microsoft CopilotMistralPerplexity

Your rank by question#5Who are the best hotels in Long Island, NY?#8I need a hotel in Long Island, NY. Who do you recommend?Not rankedBest affordable hotel near Long Island?

Named by 3 of 12 assistants that answered · 5 mentions · edition of November 1, 2026 · see the full hotels list

AI Heat · Hotels

Holding steady

How it works
59out of 100
You+4ptsAI reach since Oct 2026
Top 10 here−0.7ptsaverage since Oct 2026
Your edge+4ptsyou minus the market

AI reach, out of 100 How often AI assistants name this business, and how high in their answers. 100 means named first by every assistant on every question.

0102036Oct 2026Nov 2026
The MenhadenAverage of the top 10 on this list

AI reach 6, up 4 points since October 2026, while the top 10 here fell 0.7. Hotter than 59% of the 31,317 businesses on lists measured in both editions.

Is this your business?

Want to beat your competitors?

Holiday Inn Long Island–Islip Airport East sits at #8, one place above you, and 3 assistants name a business above you but not you. Our platform shows The Menhaden which assistants skip you, which sources they read instead, and the fixes that move you up, re-checked every week until the answer changes. Everything on this page is free. The $49 AI Report shows what this page can’t: what the AIs get wrong about you, why they pick someone else, and exactly what to fix.

Free · you’re looking at it

Your AI ranking

$0

  • Your rank in every category, edition by edition
  • The AI heat map and who’s ahead of you
  • What the assistants say about you
  • The sites they read about you

Free. Confirm by email, then one note per edition. Unsubscribe anytime.

One-time · no subscription

AI Report for The Menhaden

$49 once

This page shows where you rank. The report shows why, and what to fix. Only in the report:

  • Every wrong fact the AIs tell customers about you: what each one said, next to the truth
  • Your website's AI Access score, check by check: every check it fails, and exactly how to fix it
  • You vs the #1, side by side: the sites AI cites for them and never for you
  • The sites AI cites for your competitors, not you: where to get listed next
  • A 90-day plan, week by week: what to fix, how, and who does it, written so your web person can follow it as is

Plus everything on the free page, in one PDF.

In your inbox within minutes. No subscription. Buying it never changes a ranking.

Popular

Ongoing · cancel anytime

AI Pulse

$99/mo

The report is one snapshot. AI Pulse keeps all of it running and gives you the tools to fix it:

  • The AI Report's checks, kept live, re-run across all 12 AIs every week, not once
  • An alert when an AI gets a fact wrong, with the correction written for you
  • One ranked fix list, with step-by-step instructions, or hand it to your web person or coding agent
  • Up to 25 competitors tracked head to head, so you see the week a rival overtakes you
  • Your reviews watched, and happy customers asked for new ones automatically
  • Your Google Business Profile and map spot, checked for what's holding them back
  • Articles drafted for you to publish, plus the page labels AI reads to understand you
  • The leads AI sends you, traced back to the assistant that sent them
  • A weekly summary in your inbox, so you never have to log in to know where you stand

Every feature, all 12 AIs. Month to month.

Get AI Pulse See what AI Pulse looks like

Where the assistants read about The Menhaden

6 sites were cited in the answers that named The Menhaden; most often gurneysresorts.com (1×), cntraveler.com (1×) and theroundtreehotels.com (1×). Its own site, themenhaden.com, was cited 1×.

  1. 01 gurneysresorts.comRanked #2 · Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa 1 of 12 assistants
  2. 02 cntraveler.com 1 of 12 assistants
  3. 03 theroundtreehotels.comRanked #7 · The Roundtree 1 of 12 assistants
  4. 04 shousugibanhouse.comRanked #14 · Shou Sugi Ban House 1 of 12 assistants
  5. 05 themenhaden.comThis business 1 of 12 assistants
  6. 06 caperesorts.comRanked #15 · The Pridwin 1 of 12 assistants

Key facts

The Menhaden at a glance

Business
The Menhaden
Market
Long Island, NY
Category
Hotels
Rank
#9 of 25
AI assistants naming it
3 of 12 that answered
Named in
5 of 35 answers (top 3 in 1)
Named first by
DeepSeek
#1 in this market
Sound View Greenport
Edition
November 1, 2026

Cite this ranking

The Menhaden ranks #9 of 25 hotels in Long Island, NY, named by 3 of 12 AI assistants (AI Local by AI Syndicate, November 2026 edition). https://www.aisyndicate.com/ai-local/new-york/long-island/business/the-menhaden/

Measured by asking 12 AI assistants the same questions in every market. Methodology.

Common questions

What is The Menhaden's website?

The Menhaden's website is https://themenhaden.com/, the site the AI assistants' own answers point to for this business in Long Island, NY, and checked to be this business's own website.

Do AI assistants recommend The Menhaden?

Yes. In the edition of November 1, 2026, 3 of the 12 assistants that answered named The Menhaden when asked for hotels in Long Island, NY: ChatGPT, DeepSeek, Gemini. It ranks #9 for hotels.

Where does The Menhaden rank for hotels in Long Island, NY?

#9 of 25, named by 3 of the 12 assistants that answered, across 5 mentions, up 11 places from #20 in the previous edition.

What do AI assistants say about The Menhaden?

Asked for hotels, the assistants described The Menhaden with statements such as "Greenport", "16-room", "best North Fork hotel", "boutique": their own words, recorded as given and not verified by us. Positive in all 5 answers that described it.

Which AI assistants don't recommend The Menhaden?

In the edition of November 1, 2026, Google AI Overviews, Alexa, Claude, Microsoft Copilot, Grok, Meta AI, Mistral, Perplexity and Siri answered the question for hotels in Long Island, NY without naming The Menhaden.

Who ranks ahead of The Menhaden in Long Island, NY?

Sound View Greenport (#6), The Roundtree (#7), Holiday Inn Long Island–Islip Airport East (#8). Holiday Inn Long Island–Islip Airport East is one place ahead, named by 2 assistants across 2 mentions. La Quinta is one place behind at #10.

Which AI assistants name The Menhaden first?

In the edition of November 1, 2026, DeepSeek named The Menhaden first in at least one answer about hotels in Long Island, NY. Across all 35 answers, the assistants named it in 5, 1 of them in the top 3.

Why do AI assistants recommend The Garden City Hotel over The Menhaden?

The answers that named The Garden City Hotel, the #1 for hotels in Long Island, NY, cited expedia.com, tripadvisor.com, google.com, linkedin.com, en.wikipedia.org; none of the answers that named The Menhaden did. That shows where the leader appears, not proof of why it was picked.

Something wrong on this page, or not your website? Tell us and we'll correct it: wrong link, wrong business, or anything else.
Contact support@aisyndicate.com
Rankings summarize what the AI assistants answered on a fixed, unbranded question set. They measure AI output and are not AI Syndicate's endorsement of any business. Placement cannot be bought. Full detail in the methodology.

More in Long Island, NY: every category we track · Hotels ranking · how this is measured